The fence can be seen easily. The wall can be seen clearly. Each building appears to be in its correct location.
But when a property dispute occurs, the question "Does the visible boundary match the legal boundary?" can create issues with the entire map.
An orthomosaic created by a drone is very good for showing what exists physically on the ground. However, it was not designed to show where the law states one piece of land ends and another starts. These are two separate questions, and combining them can lead to expensive errors.
We've previously covered why having a 5 cm Ground Sample Distance (GSD) does not translate into 5 cm accuracy; we've discussed if a drone-collected data set is suitable for engineering applications; and we've also demonstrated how a smooth terrain model could hide a missing ditch. The same pattern applies to land administration. A beautiful, clearly defined map can answer a completely different question than the one you are actually asking.
What an Orthomosaic Shows, and What a Boundary Is
An orthomosaic is a geometrically corrected picture of the area on the date of the flight. This image displays such things as fences, walls, roads, buildings, tracks, crop edges, and other indications of occupancy. Each of these items represents evidence regarding what type of use the property has experienced.
A legal boundary is different. A legal boundary is a line defined by records (e.g., title deeds, registered plans, cadastral maps) and the monuments/marks which indicate the records on the ground. A boundary can also be determined in some systems by agreement of neighbors, registry, or court. The image can show what is there. It cannot tell you what the record indicates.
Why a Fence or Wall May Not Follow the Boundary
Fences can be built for many different reasons: to provide space to work around, to find easier terrain to build on, to keep livestock in, and sometimes simply because an earlier landowner had put the fence in place decades earlier. In some instances, the fence follows the boundary line exactly. In others, it does not. On a professional forum, surveyors have expressed clearly that a fence may or may not be evidence of a property boundary; in some instances, a fence has effectively become the boundary through the actions of adjacent landowners. Whether a particular fence establishes a boundary is a decision that must be made by a surveyor, and in certain areas, a court. The photograph itself cannot determine which of these circumstances exist.
The surveyors who were participating in the discussion described what type of questions to ask when considering a fence:
- Who built it, and why?
- How did they decide where to put it?
- Did it come before the deed that describes the line?
- Does it resemble the line described in the record?
Walls create the same problem. A record can place the boundary relative to the wall, either on one side, in the middle of, or completely off of the wall, and the picture doesn't identify where that location is.
How a Sharp Orthomosaic Creates False Confidence
Sharp looks precise. Resolution describes the degree to which a picture displays details. Penn State's orthophoto course states directly that spatial accuracy and pixel size are completely unrelated. Thus, a high-quality sharp image may be far removed from where it should be on the Earth, a subject that has been discussed at length in our article regarding GSD and accuracy.
Height creates offsets. Orthorectification corrects for the effects of terrain. However, elevated features (such as roofs and wall tops) can be offset even after being processed in an orthomosaic, depending on how the orthomosaic was created. According to Pima County, parcel lines that have been properly positioned may seem to intersect with building roofs due to building lean. Additionally, the amount of displacement changes with the angle of view when the image is captured at a different angle than previous ones, while ground-level features do not move. If the user understands that these anomalies exist, then this is merely a minor annoyance. However, if the user measures from a roof edge or wall top and considers that measurement as a boundary distance, then this situation becomes problematic.
A drawn line looks professional. Add a colored line, a measurement, and a title block to a sharp picture, and the map will start to look like a survey. People will interpret it as such no matter what the legend says.
Records, Monuments, Coordinate Systems and Licensed Surveyors
Records aren't all equal
In each country, there are various methods used to define the boundaries of properties. The first issue is therefore what the records in your specific area indicate. For instance, in England and Wales, unless a boundary has been formally determined, registered title plans indicate general boundaries. Official copies of such plans carry a warning that the plan indicates the general position of boundaries, but not their precise location. Therefore, even the official record may leave the precise location of boundaries undefined.
Cadastral GIS layers aren't survey-grade by default
Parcel layers used in a GIS are generally generated from other sources (i.e., derived), and the publishers of these layers indicate that they are. A California county's parcel base was created by using assessor tax maps that were placed in relation to aerial imagery; therefore, the base is not considered survey-grade, and any differences between what appears on the map and legal records must be verified. A Virginia county's GIS disclaimer states that its information is not intended to take the place of a professional survey or deed search; also, the disclaimer warns that there may be some discrepancies between how closely the map layers align with the aerial imagery. On a professional forum, a surveyor reported that county parcel lines can vary anywhere from 5 to 20 feet away from where the actual boundary lies, based upon the specific subdivision. There is another valuable lesson to keep in mind when viewing the discussion in this thread: a disclaimer does not create accuracy within data for purposes that it is not designed to serve.
So overlaying a parcel layer on a high-resolution orthomosaic and measuring the gap to the fence gives you a precise distance to an imprecise line.
Monuments
Boundary retracement is to locate the original surveyed or conveyed line, not where today's measurement says the line would have been located. This is how boundary retracement is defined in a land surveying exam study manual. For years, physical monuments have been given priority by common-law courts over written descriptions of distance. Alta Land Survey cites a frequently used New Mexico decision that lists natural boundaries first, then artificial marks, adjoining boundaries, and course and distance, with area the weakest, on the reasoning that mistakes are more likely in courses and distances than in visible, permanent objects. Surveyors treat that order as a guide to intent rather than a rigid rule.
Either way, you will need to find the monument, determine if it is the correct monument, and then assess the condition of that monument. While a drone image may indicate where a monument is likely to be, it will not indicate if the monument shown is the original, if there has been disturbance at the site of the monument, or if the monument is the one referred to in the deed.
Coordinate systems
Cadastral data typically arrives in a national or local grid and datum. Drone data is generally provided in WGS 84, UTM, etc., or as a project grid. Without properly transforming the two types of data, the parcel layer will sit offset from the drone-derived image. The resulting offset can appear identical to an encroachment. We covered how datum mismatches cost clients' trust in drone deliverables.
Licensed surveying
In many places, determining a legal boundary is reserved for licensed or authorized surveyors, and the rules differ by jurisdiction. As reported in ENR, the California board typically files 10 to 15 actions per year against drone users they believe to be performing unlicensed surveying. On the other hand, the North Carolina board has taken a more expansive definition of what is considered surveying. Before drawing a boundary line on a map, review the regulations that apply to your work location.
When Drone Imagery Can Support a Boundary Investigation, and When It Can't
The use of drone imagery can be beneficial to a boundary investigation when it is used as an effective tool for the things that it does well:
- documenting existing conditions as of a specific date: fencing, walls, structures, walkways, and points of entry
- planning the field work: where to look for monuments, what obstacles exist, and what kind of access is required
- flagging potential discrepancies between what is documented (the record) and what is actually being occupied physically, so that they may be investigated
- providing an up-to-date and high-quality background for GIS parcel mapping, where each layer has a clear label
- producing visual exhibits and showing change over time
It can't replace authoritative survey evidence when the question is:
- where the legal boundary actually lies
- whether a monument is original and undisturbed
- how to resolve a conflict between the record, the monuments and the occupation
- what position can be certified for a transaction or a dispute
There is, however, an important counter-example. In "fit-for-purpose" land administration, promoted jointly by FIG and the World Bank, aerial and satellite imagery can be used to identify parcels at scale (using general boundaries instead of fixed ones), with participation from the community. This approach can work as long as the legal system recognizes it and as long as property owners and neighbors participate in the process, not because the image itself is obviously correct. The technology remains essentially the same; however, the legal basis for using the technology and the overall goal for using the technology are different. That is the key.
A Practical Workflow
When a project requires both drone mapping and land ownership data, here is how we will proceed with our workflow:
- Define the purpose and the jurisdiction. How will you use the map? Who controls it? Do you have to hire a licensed surveyor? This is the step in our pre-survey checklist about confirming what the deliverable is actually for.
- Obtain the records. Deeds or titles, registered plans, cadastral maps, previous surveys, and monument descriptions.
- Establish your control and your coordinate system. Link the drone survey to the established control of your reference system that is used for records. Document all data transformations.
- Fly and process with independent checkpoints, and report the accuracy in a way that can be verified.
- Overlay the records onto the orthomosaic, labeling each record's layer based on its source and reliability.
- Flag discrepancies; don't resolve them. Mark the conflict as "to be investigated" rather than "encroachment" when there is a difference between the physical boundary (e.g., fence, wall, building) and the written record.
- Verify in the field. Find and measure monuments and evaluate the evidence. When required by law, a licensed surveyor performs these activities.
- Provide clear labels. Clearly identify the measurements taken, the sources used (records), and the interpretations made; explicitly state that the visible features on the land do not represent legal property lines unless they were determined by a legally recognized method.
The Actual Takeaway
A drone map provides good proof of what exists on the land. A boundary is a legal determination based upon the use of records, monuments, and applicable laws. If you keep the two separate, yet demonstrate how they relate to one another, your map will be of greater value to you, rather than lesser.
If your project needs drone mapping combined with cadastral data and parcel mapping, and you want it clear which parts are measured, which come from records, and which still need field verification, that is the planning our GIS, topographic survey, and drone imaging and processing teams do before the first flight.
The above article provides general information regarding the practice of mapping. It does not provide legal advice. There are variations in how boundary laws and surveying regulations apply across jurisdictions.